Ben Tremblay

Technology, business and change

List posts are popular. Give me analysis.

I’ve never been a huge fan of posts with topics such as “top 15 tools to…”. You know, I’ve found some blogs that successfully made those lists useful, but I feel that the added value is usually very low. Sure they do well in the search engines and are easy to read and share on social media platforms, but I much prefer a good analysis instead of a list and here’s why.

I stumbled upon an article on Mashable that express my feeling about “list posts”: Twittermania: 140+ More Twitter Tools!

140twittertools

I understand the funny reference to twitter with the 140 tools, but what really is the added value of such posts? I highly respect Mashable, but they do post a lot of similar articles and they spread viraly and I’m sure you know a lot of other blogs doing so. It’s not an isolated case.

I mean, what is the benefit of listing 140 tools, do you really expect me to try all of them? Of course not. That’s why I want an analysis. It’s easy to break down this post into 10 other posts that could be called something like “10 twitter clients compared”. Now that’s a useful post. But more work.

I can’t take any action with 140 twitter tools listed in a post, but I can surely take action after reading a comparison of 10 twitter tools. I don’t want to know every tool that is available to me, I want to know the best tools and why.

That’s the same reason why companies are ready to pay a lot of money for experts’ advices: they don’t have time to evaluate every single solution, they simply pay someone to do the evaluation and give them the top 3 options in a nice report.

You know, there are reasons why lists are popular and you might like them, but I just prefer a good analysis.

Receive updates by email



14 Réponses pour “List posts are popular. Give me analysis.”

  1. Paul says:

    I definitely agree with you on this. A lot of list posts really don't contribute much content at all, they're just intended to generate traffic.

  2. Yes, you are right. Before i had also ignored many these topics but later found it some of them really true and useful. Thanks for this info. It really helps other people also.

  3. I agree. I think its because they are trying to optimize their site, even when the content is ridiculous.

  4. i also agree with you..
    i also go for good analysis before doing anything with side

  5. Thoma Daneau says:

    they're just intended to generate traffic.I agree with you said.

  6. Yes, I agree with this post, They jut want to get more traffic from there and nothing more they pretend to do with that. Nice info

  7. used tires says:

    There are times when lists are good, and there are times when an analysis is good, but most of the time… I think an analysis is the better route to go. Lists are just fun… but an analysis is for the real players.

    Till then,

    Jean

  8. Kin Lau says:

    I think a list post is great, give me a lot of option to choose from and know what could be useful.

  9. Hey this is really awesome. Nice source of info

  10. Roxanne says:

    I agree with you. I am a newbie in this field. Thanks for sharing this, I really don't know how to use tools in twitter.

  11. they're just intended to generate traffic. I agree with this post. Marketing have change it face.

  12. john says:

    When promoting your website through posts… there is a fine line between healthy commenting and spam. But as long as you are making a contribution to the site the admin team can always moderate comments which they feel are inappropriate or spam.

    Blog on !!!

Qu'en pensez-vous?

Receive updates by email:

rss feed RSS twitter benoit tremblay twitter